How a debate runs
- Each AI answers on its own.
- They review each other's answers and refine their own.
- If they agree after one honest review, it's settled. If they genuinely differ, they keep talking.
- A model that took no part gives the verdict, with anything still in dispute and the stronger case for each side.
You can join in at any point: add a point or side with one of them, and the next to speak answers you first.
A real run: 54 seconds, $0.12
Our 6-person accounting firm keeps client tax files in a cloud portal. Should we turn on two-factor sign-in for all staff? Both said yes from the start. Each reviewed the other's answer and refined its own once, and they agreed, so it settled after one review.
When to use it
Decisions where being wrong is expensive: a policy, a vendor choice, a legal reading, a strategy call. For routine document work use a job instead; it's far cheaper.
Questions people ask
Which is better, GPT or Claude?
It depends on the question, which is the point of an AI debate: both answer, both review the other's answer, and you see where they agree and where they don't.
What is LLM-as-a-judge?
Using one model to grade or decide between other models' answers. In an AI debate the verdict comes from a model that took no part in it.
How much does a debate cost?
Usually 5 to 60 cents, shown before it runs.